Robin,
I too had a very fairy tale idealization of marriage. His LTA burst that bubble - and I have grown from that. The romanticized version we held was… well… for children. It’s not the real world. I learned this at age 50, so this was a deeply held belief. I think you should discuss this with your therapist. Authentic marriage, not idealized, is a lot messier. And it also means we don’t put up with stuff that is not serving us or the M well.
It reads that you and your WS are not discussing the A at all - not just this one time where you brought it up, but at all. Is that correct or am I mis-reading your post? Is this because you are not bringing it up, he is not bringing it up, or both? And why not? Have you told him what you need when you bring things up like you did this week? Does he usually respond in an healthy and helpful way? Or does he dodge the conversation to discuss later and then never bring it back up again? And is this his normal reaction?
Is he in IC? What is going on there if he is?
What does your IC say when you talk about how to broach tough subjects with him? if your IC can’t help with this… then I have concerns abut your IC. Might be time to switch IC up. My first IC could not take me there either - I switched therapists and he helped me find my spine and identify what I needed.
Fear of the future is real, but it is largely unfounded. You might look at the pinned post in the S/D forum where folks have weighed in on what they feared and what actually happened. It’s pretty enlightening. Not saying D is easy - it is not - but most of what we feared never came to pass.
31 is not so late that you can’t D him, meet someone new, and have kids. Or consider other options - IVF, adoption, etc. Lots of ways to have kids. And why are you not discussing this with your H? I understand for the first year after DDAY that it should be off the table. Are you not pushing it because you secretly feel he will not be the right partner for you to raise kids with? Or are you afraid he will say no to kids? In either case, you are better off cutting your losses now. In five years, you will have fewer options.
And as for your comment that it takes some people longer to realize that this is not enough— meh. Took me a year. Takes some less time, some more time. it takes as long as it takes.
Lastly, PLEASE re-engage with family and friends. you need them. They provide a critical outlet and counterbalance from walking on eggshells and the bubble of the A. Whether you stay with your WS or D, you need them in your life. Reach out by calling them and meeting for coffee or brunch or whatever. Don’t let his A take them from you. If they are not interested in being near your WS, then okay, See them by yourself. This is you living intentionally.
it’s good you are seeking a way to live a happier, more intentional life. Keep pushing that agenda. You are stronger than you know, and I think you are on the cusp of change. Good luck!