"But then there was the part where I couldn’t fully reach him emotionally, I used to joke that we cannot argue as he was refusing to engage in any argument."
I experienced precisely this in our marriage. I used to sometimes tell him that it felt that I loved him far more then he loved me. I told him I felt there was this barrier between us, that there wasn't the emotional connection between us that there should be. He used to just tell me that I was being daft, list the "ways" he shows he clearly does love me. He couldn't quite grasp the idea that just because he (same as your husband) spent all of his time with us and wasn't having lads nights out like other people he knew, that it could possibly be true. He thought because we both enjoyed the same stuff, shared the same humour and were always very affectionate, that this IS an emotional connection. He would then become very stone-wally. And I would start to doubt myself and believed my expectations were too high - until the same knawing doubts came back.
We didn't really used to argue either. He was far too horizontal for that. I never really saw him angry. Even when his ex alienated him from his older children, I wondered where the fire was in his belly. He used to be so passive. We used to joke that he was dead inside 😪
I think the worst thing for me, was that I never really felt like he had my back. I used to worry, what if I get cancer, or even just break a leg. How will *I* get the kids to school. How will *I* support the kids. How will *I* cope. I felt that should the sh!t hit the fan, I'll be on my own. I didn't feel like I had a team mate, not really. But he never saw it, because you know, he did his fair share around the house and was a great hands on dad that never missed a sports day.
Unfortunately sh!t did hit the fan on a few occasions pre-dday. Sadly he proved my fears correct. I was a one man band, with him more concerned that I wasn't giving him or the kids enough attention.
However, moving forward - do I think he would be there for me in time of crisis? A very reserved yes. Do I feel like there is an emotional connection? Yes, but its clouded with doubt that what I'm seeing is temporary.
I totally understand what you are saying, when you say that going through tough experiences together post dday, can rebuild the marriage.
And like I say, I admire you so much for your strength in rebuilding your marriage and finding happiness together again. And Oldwounds, the fact that you can offer so much grace to your wife...you are both truly amazing people.
So WHY is it that the idea of me doing the exact same thing, and extending any grace, leaves me wallowing in my pit of shame? Why am I living by one rule for me, another for everyone else???