I don’t know your age or if this is your first marriage or not, but here’s my two cents.
Trust is broken. Can it be repaired? Maybe. But just know you will always have a nagging doubt (it’s only normal). For some people that’s more than they want to live with.
Now he’s an alcoholic? Hmmmm…..is that the truth or is he using it as an excuse to hide behind.
He didn’t admit anything until YOU uncovered the truth. He gets no credit there.
Obviously you know he’s got issues. He chose to cheat for a stupid reason (thrill of it, whatever lie he told himself to justify his behavior) but that is not your problem to fix.
If you want to D him, you should. However that doesn’t mean you cannot have a future relationship w/ him (or not). It just means you are not H&W. That could be permanent or somewhere down the road you choose to Reconcile and be in a committed relationship. But I would suggest not re-marrying him until and unless you are sure. That could take years (if ever).
However it will be a very different relationship b/c you will never fully trust him. It’s just the fallout from the fact he cheated on you for years. He may be 100% faithful to you for the rest of his life but there will always be a black mark.
I don’t think you are over reacting. For some people cheating is a dealbreaker. Live apart. Take some time for yourself. Give yourself a chance to breathe.
As for him, watch. See. Pay attention.
Is he in therapy for more than 2 or 3 sessions? Is he doing things to try to Reconcile w/ you w/out looking for guarantees or promises from you? Is he working AS HARD 3 or 6 months from now or has he given up?
Words are easy. I’d suggest watching his actions if you think there is a chance to MAYBE have a future.
But I’d also make sure he knows you are now calling the shots. Don’t listen to his "poor me" sob story.
Honestly if I had D my H after his first affair, I would not have been subjected to a second affair. If SI had been around then, I would have learned so much and avoided the pain and suffering of a 2nd affair.
I think the fact you took action is impressive!
[This message edited by The1stWife at 3:45 AM, Tuesday, April 22nd]