I have (and am in a way) still going through the same thing - but honestly I cannot imagine not trying something different and just sticking with that feeling. I mean you have to ask yourself, how much suffering is just too much?
You know that saying: "Absence makes the heart go fonder"? Well while I don't think that's necessarily true I do think that a little bit of absence can bring some clarity. And my friend, it's clarity that you need.
In my case after d-day1 I felt JUST like you described:
But I still felt the love that has always been our base, our anchor, I felt that I still wanted us, wanted to fight for us. This was also why I decided to give WH a second chance
That was me all day long. I had the distinct displeasure of having a d-day 2, and those feelings, while not totally dissolved, were weakened a little, but I still loved him - still thought there was a chance, in the beginning. But fast forward like 9 months and I felt just "blah" - again, much like you describe:
I see changes in him, it's just they came after more struggle and at a higher cost than I could stand. And now I find myself feeling more and more numb. I no longer go into that deep turmoil, but I also no longer feel any really good feelings in pur relationship. Even when we are in a really good place, it's like I'm just numb. I can't really access that feeling of love or belonging or happiness anymore
Eventually, I decided to leave. So WH and I divorced and then I moved out and far away (did D first then move out due to COVID) - and I really thought I would be gone for good. But the distance helped me appreciate the positive changes in WH and in myself...and I realized I did miss him. At first it was slow - but I found myself missing things about "us" and enjoying talking to him more because he was no longer in the "R" context - I mean there was nothing holding us together anymore, but us.
I'm not suggesting divorcing...I AM suggesting to at minimum, take some time for yourself. Like real time - time that you can get away from that situation and do other things with other people (I don't mean anything akin to cheating). Take a vacation by yourself or with friends - in other words, disconnect a bit from your WS and find YOU. You may find that you want to share more with your WS...that some of that longing and friendship and looking forward to talking to you comes back. Or you may not. In which case you will know where you stand.
And I do not think it is outside of the realm of okay to tell your WS exactly how you feel and what you intend to do about it. I mean my gosh, if a BS needs a bit of time to themselves to figure out if they want to continue with a relationship after it's been gutted by the other half, or if they just want a little time to themselves, they should have it.
For me and WH, even now, 5 years post-end-of-A it's not all roses. We now date again and some of those feelings you are missing now did indeed return, but not all of them, and I realize that some of them just aren't going to. The pedestal I had WH on in my mind is long gone as are the crazy "can't wait to see you" feelings I used to have, even when I was gone for a few days. I used to travel quite a bit and I would miss WH almost immediately, and while not pining away or anything, was super happy to come home. Put another way, it always seemed like every trip, no matter how great the location and the company and no matter how much fun I had, would always be better if WH were there too.
It's not like that for me anymore. But for me, that's okay. I have discovered that I don't think I want such a tied-down commitment as I used to have with WH. I don't want to date anyone else - I just want to spend more time with me and friends and family and not have to coordinate schedules...and sometimes, unlike before, the trip would not always be better if WH were there to share it. I have my own fun now (and it's not like I wasn't independent before WH - I had plenty of fantastic times on my own), and I like it.
But for you OP - I do not think it is a BSs duty to sit through POLF or the realization that the A may have been the marriage-ender you didn't think it was for some extended period of time. To me the POLF is when your mind finally slows down - the heart pounding madness/craziness/emotional whiplash of the A/post-A has slowed - and you can take a minute to reassess where you actually are and what you want to do about it. You've been fighting so long to save the burning pile of crap your WS created that you haven't had time to look and see what it is you've actually saved, and if you really want it after all. You now know what you have - and you're not too excited about it - shocking. That does not mean toss it out - it means figure out if it really is still what you want, and giving yourself some uncluttered space to do it.
EDIT:
I didn't see that you said this:
There is no real conversation between us at the moment and I keep more and more to myself. It's not that I don't want to as much as I feel like I just can't? I feel stuck in this no-man's land of feelings. I almost feel like I would rather feel rage than feel nothing? at least I would feel something then.
I'm not suggesting you do that kind of keeping to yourself. I am suggesting that you do some purposeful me-time activities, and just come out with it and say so. In all honestly in the time I was in POLF-land, before I realized I could extract myself from that at any time, I think this - what you all are doing - would have sent me further into my shell:
We have been doing an intensive 6 week program in couples therapy as well that we are in the middle of and that has been very emotional and has taken a toll on us both. It's sort of an intensive emotionally based program where you dig really really deep into underlying fears behind coping behaviours and attachment models. It's been very intense so that might play into things a bit as well, we are both slightly emotionally burnt out from it all and there's a lot to process in between sessions every week. So that might be part of it also.
I mean my gosh that sounds like the last thing I would have wanted to do at the stage you are at - intensive couples therapy. IMO you really are at that point where you are assessing what you have and what you want to do with it so it's not the time to try to do some team-building. Instead it's time for you to decide if YOU want to remain part of the team and I think some intensive YOU-time is in order.
[This message edited by ThisIsSoLonely at 8:41 PM, Thursday, October 10th]